The world ofPaliais calm and peaceful, but underneath it all, there’s still a somewhat seedy underbelly thanks to how magic is restricted. Sometimes people have to hide what they do, and Tish suspects her brother Reth might be up to something. He’s been secretive, out at all hours of the night, and his work has suffered for it enough to be noticeable.
Due to Tish’s close relationship with her brother, it’s difficult for her to confront him directly about his strange activities, and she needs a helping hand figuring it all out. It’s up to you to help her discover Reth’s secret, and in this guide, we’ll tell you how to help both Tish and Reth with their problems.

How To Unlock The Quest
To unlock this quest, you’ll need to reach aroundlevel three friendship with Tish, and have completedboth or all threeof her prior friendship quests. This can be done bygifting her liked itemsonce a real-world day,talking with hereach in-game day, andfulfilling her weekly wants.
Tish’s liked items includeany Treasure Chest,Silk Thread,Silk,Sundrop Lillies,Pearls,Chapaa Fur,Leather,Copper Bars,Iron Bars,Fabric,Shells,Briar Daisies,Sernuk Hide, or aWagon Wheel. As Secrets, Secrets technically does not count as a friendship quest, unlocking it canvary slightlydepending on what you’ve done.

This quest directly relates to Reth, and completing histhird friendship quest,Piece of Cake before Secrets, Secrets will lock you out of this quest. Havingboth quests at the same timewill still allow you to progress Secrets, Secrets normally.
If youhaven’t completedPiece of Cake, buthavecompletedTish’s level three friendship quest, Rage Redecoration, you’llunlock this quest automatically.

When the quest appears,speak to Tish, and she’ll tell you that she’s worried about her brother Reth. She asks you to find outwhat he’s been hidingfrom her.
How To Find Out Reth’s Secret
With this quest, you’ll need tobefriend Reth.You’ll also want tochat with Ashuraeach day enough to unlock the quest,Errands for Reth, and complete it, as this quest technically counts towards Reth’s relationship andgives you relationship points with him.
Like with Tish and other characters, you canraise your relationshipwith him bygifting him liked items, speaking to him, and fulfilling his weekly wants.
Reth’sliked itemsincludecooking ingredientslikeSweet Leaf,Wild Garlic,Tomatoes,Potatoes,Onions,Heat Roots, Bahari Crabs,Carrots,Apples,Chapaa Meat,Sernuk Meat, andSpice Sprouts.
He alsoaccepts cooked disheslike Fish Stew,Hearty Vegetable Soup, Creamy Carrot Soup, Palian Onion Soup, Loaded Potato Soup, Cream of Tomato Soup,Meaty Stir Fry, orRamen.
During Secrets, Secrets is alsothe best timeto completePiece of Cake, where you’ll need topick up and deliver a secret packageto Tamala for Reth, then report back to him.
During that quest, you’ll find out about hissecret and not-so-legal side businessthat he uses to support Tish and himself, and that heworks with Zekiand other Grimalkynes smuggling magical cargo.
Now that you know Reth’s secret,the quest will update, and you’ll need tohead back to Tish.
What Answer Should You Give Tish?
Speak to Tish, and you’ll havethree choices availableregarding the situation: not revealing Reth’s secret, telling her the truth, or opting against saying anything in case it comes between them.
You’refree to pick whichever optionyou want, and they mainly affect Tish’s message to you in herlevel four friendship quest, Make ‘Em Sing. The message’s contents willchange slightlydepending on which of the three options you choose.